Tuesday, March 9, 2010

The Misfits


The Misfits is written by James Howe. This book documents four friends during their 7th grade year - Bobby, Addie, Skeezie and Joe. These four friends all consider themselves "misfits" - they have been called every name in the book and form their pack based on their differences. Hoping to bring an end to name-calling in their middle school "the gang of five", as they refer to themselves, start a new third political party just in time for their school elections. There are the usual parties - the Democrats and the Republicans - and now there is the Freedom Party (later to be called "The No-Name Party"). These kids fight hard during their run for the win to make positive changes in their school. Meanwhile, all four kids face their fair share of difficulties in their life and we're particularly brought into the narrator's life - Bobby. Bobby has always been called names like, "Fatso", "Lardo" and "Fluff", etc. due to his weight. However, his weight gain was due to the death of his mother in elementary school. Bobby is awkward and shy, yet highly intellectual and well-spoken. The other members of "the gang of five" face taunts about their style, their height, their brains and their sexuality. At the end of the book, Bobby gives a terrific election speech for "The No-Name Party" and his school loves it. However, "The No-Name Party" ends up losing the election by a hair. But the school remains changed forever - valuing The No-Name Party's motives to end the vicious cycle of name-calling. And Bobby's crush, Kelsey, asks him to the school dance.

I never read this book as a middle-school-aged student myself, but I can see from reading it now it's importance and value in the classroom. This book would be interesting to read for students in middle school because of the format - there was a lot of conversation, play-like format which was easy and fun to read as the conversation bounced back and forth between the main characters. This book would also initiate a great conversation between the teacher and her students. It's important to discuss hurtful names in school because those names are tossed around all the time and do more damage than students dishing them out may know. I certainly remember all of the names I was called in Middle School - "Skinny Mini", "Lanky", "Prude", etc. And all of those names really stung and have stuck with me forever. I would like to talk about the pain name-calling can cause in my classroom and discuss why name-calling is not allowed in school or anywhere.

I do not find this book controversial in the slightest. Joe, the character who is gay, is fairly flamboyant but the boy who he has a crush on and ends up dating is the opposite, creating a realistic balance. Additionally the inappropriate names are appropriate because they're the reality of middle school. Name-calling happens all the time and the damage can sometimes be irreversible. This book effectively discusses these names and makes it clear why they are inappropriate.

I also think the book is very relatable - many students will be able to identify with one of the four main characters. I even related with Addie myself as an adult. This book was not as enjoyable for me to read as The Giver was, but I certainly can see why it would be a popular choice among middle school students and this book would be welcome in my classroom and a great read-aloud.

No comments:

Post a Comment